What makes a diamond behave differently from a fake?

A diamond is carbon with a hardness of 10 and a refractive index of 2.42, in the FTC's definition. GIA's comparison of colorless diamond and its simulants adds that it is singly refractive, with a dispersion of 0.044 and a specific gravity of 3.52. Every stand-in misses on at least one of those, and each test looks for a miss. With inherited jewelry that has no paperwork, those properties are all there is to go on.

SimulantHow it differs from diamondWhich check exposes it
Cubic zirconiaHardness 8 to 8.5, and far heavier, with a specific gravity of 5.56 to 6.00A thermal tester
Synthetic moissaniteHardness 9.25, doubly refractive, and a dispersion of 0.104Doubled back facets under magnification, or an electrical-conductivity test. A thermal tester alone does not.
Colorless sapphireHardness 9, a refractive index near 1.77, and much less brilliantA thermal tester, and print reads clearly through it
GlassOften made in a mold, so facet edges can be rounded, and it can hold gas bubblesMagnification, by someone trained to read it

Which home checks tell you something, and which can fool you?

GIA's verdict comes first: there are no easy and reliable at-home tests that will settle it. The checks below can raise a doubt. None can clear one.

CheckWhat you doWhat it can showWhat fools it
Fog testBreathe on the stone and watch the fog clearNothing dependableItself. GIA says it cannot be repeated with consistent results.
Newspaper or read-through testLay a loose stone face down on printPrint that reads clearly points to a low-index simulant such as colorless sapphireMoissanite shows no read-through, the same as diamond, and cubic zirconia only a slight one
Loupe, for inclusionsLook inside the stone at 10xVery little. Imitations can have inclusions too.Gas bubbles in glass look like natural inclusions to an untrained eye
Loupe, for facet edgesLook at the facet junctions, then through the stone at an angleDoubled back facets suggest moissanite. Rounded junctions suggest molded glass or plastic.Doubling rarely shows face up, and a real diamond can have abraded edges
SparkleJudge the stone by how bright it looksNothingA diamond that does not sparkle is still a diamond
Scratch or sandpaper testDo not do itNothing worth the damageGIA calls it destructive and says it should never be used

Two things limit all of them. A mounted stone cannot be laid on print and is hard to see from the side, which is where moissanite's doubling shows. And the ring itself is no evidence: GIA says the metal alone is not a definitive clue. If the setting is what you are unsure of, that is a separate question, covered in how to tell if gold jewelry is real.

What can a jeweler's diamond tester prove, and what can it miss?

The common handheld tester is thermal. Its probe is heated, the stone draws that heat away, and the tester reads how fast, as Presidium's handbook describes. That separates diamond from cubic zirconia, sapphire, and glass. It does not separate it from moissanite: the same handbook says no thermal tester on the market can, and in GIA's study every synthetic moissanite tested registered as diamond on thermal instruments.

Combined testers add an electrical test, because moissanite conducts electricity and most near-colorless diamonds do not. GIA treats that as indicative, never diagnostic: only 13 of the 23 moissanites in its study conducted, and some gray and blue diamonds do.

No handheld tester answers the other question, mined or laboratory-grown. GIA says traditional gemological instruments cannot tell the two apart, and a laboratory-grown stone tests as diamond because it is one. Under the FTC Jewelry Guides it has to be described as laboratory-grown or laboratory-created.

When is a lab report worth getting instead of a quick test?

When the question is mined or laboratory-grown, or when the stone matters enough that a screening result is not sufficient. For origin, GIA's advice is to send the stone to a gemological laboratory for advanced testing. A GIA Diamond Grading Report covers loose natural diamonds of 0.15 carats or more and records the full 4Cs with a plotted diagram of the stone's clarity characteristics. A report on a laboratory-grown diamond names the growth process. Neither is an appraisal: GIA states no appraisal value on its reports.

Every report carries a unique number, sometimes laser inscribed on the diamond's girdle, and GIA inscribes every laboratory-grown diamond it grades with the words Laboratory-Grown and its number. Look the number up on GIA Report Check, which verifies that a report matches GIA's database. Then make sure the stone fits the report. GIA has documented synthetic moissanite carrying a forged GIA inscription that matched a real diamond's report, so a number on the girdle is not proof by itself.

If the stone is a diamond and you are thinking of parting with it, see our page on selling diamond jewelry. Our Smyrna showroom takes walk-ins: Monday to Friday, 10 AM to 5 PM, and Saturday, 11 AM to 3 PM. Franklin and Bellevue are by appointment. Call (615) 893-2414.

This guide is general information about how diamonds and their imitations are identified, not a gemological opinion on any stone; what a stone is can only be settled by testing it.

Sources