Skip to content

Is that rare coin worth more than its metal?

Most are not, and a few are worth a great deal. This guide lists the key dates, mint marks, and errors collectors pay for, by denomination. Find your coin, check the date, then walk it into our Smyrna showroom or book a time in Franklin or Bellevue for a free appraisal.

  • Pennies and cents
  • Nickels
  • Dimes
  • Quarters
  • Half dollars
  • Silver dollars
Back to coins we buy
A Kennedy half dollar beside an open pocket watch

Follow these steps

  1. 01

    Identify your coin

    Match it to one of the six denominations below: pennies and cents, nickels, dimes, quarters, half dollars, or silver dollars.

  2. 02

    Check the date

    Find the year on the front of the coin. If it is listed under its series below, the coin may be worth more than its metal.

  3. 03

    Find the mint mark

    Look for a small letter such as D, S, O, or CC. Its position varies by coin, and some coins have none at all.

  4. 04

    Get a free appraisal

    Condition changes everything, and no list can judge it. Bring the coin in for a free appraisal and we will evaluate it in front of you.

    Schedule a free appraisal

Pennies and cents

  • Flying Eagle Cents 1856–1858

    Semi-rare dates

    Most dates carry collector value

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1856
  • Indian Head Pennies 1859–1909

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1859
    • 1861
    • 1864
    • 1864 with ‘L’ on neck
    • 1866–1876
    • 1878
    • 1908-S

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1877
    • 1909-S
  • Lincoln Cents 1909–Present

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1909-S
    • 1911-S
    • 1912-S
    • 1914-S
    • 1915-S
    • 1922-D
    • 1924-D
    • 1931-S

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1909-S VDB
    • 1914-D
    • 1922 (no D)
  • Large Cents & Half Cents Pre-1858

    Semi-rare dates

    Most dates have some collector value

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • Any 1793 coin
    • 1799 Draped Bust
    • 1804 Draped Bust

Nickels

  • Buffalo Nickels 1913–1938

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1913-S v1
    • 1913-D v2
    • 1914
    • 1914-D/S
    • 1915-D/S
    • 1916-D
    • 1917-D/S
    • 1918-D
    • 1921-S
    • 1924-S
    • 1926-S
    • 1931-S

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1913-S v2
    • 1916 Double Die
    • 1918-D (8 over 7)
    • 1937-D (3-legged buffalo)
  • Shield Nickels 1866–1883

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1866 Rays
    • 1867 Rays
    • 1871
    • 1875
    • 1876
    • 1883 (3 over 2)

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1877
    • 1878
    • 1879
    • 1880
    • 1881
  • V (Liberty) Nickels 1883–1912

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1883 Cents
    • 1884
    • 1888
    • 1894
    • 1912-S

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1885
    • 1886
  • Three Cent Nickels 1865–1889

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1879
    • 1880
    • 1882
    • 1883
    • 1888
    • 1889

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1884
    • 1885
    • 1886
    • 1887

Dimes

  • Mercury Dimes 1916–1947

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1921
    • 1921-D

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1916-D
    • 1942-P (42 over 41)
    • 1942-D (42 over 41)
  • Barber Dimes 1892–1916

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1892-S
    • 1893 (3/2)
    • 1893-O
    • 1894-O
    • 1895
    • 1895-S
    • 1896-O/S
    • 1897-O
    • 1901-S
    • 1903-S
    • 1904-S
    • 1913-S

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1894-S (only 24 known)
    • 1895-O
  • Seated Liberty Dimes 1837–1891

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1837
    • 1838-O
    • 1843-O
    • 1846
    • 1856-S
    • 1858-S
    • 1860-S
    • 1864
    • 1865
    • 1866-S
    • 1879–1881

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1844
    • 1860-O
    • 1863
    • 1866
    • 1867
    • 1870-S
    • 1871-CC
    • 1872-CC
    • 1873-CC
    • 1874-CC
    • 1885-S
  • Draped & Capped Bust Dimes 1796–1837

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1798–1803
    • 1805
    • 1807
    • 1809
    • 1811 (11 over 09)

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1796
    • 1797 all types
    • 1804
    • 1822

Quarters

  • Washington Quarters 1932–Present

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1932-D
    • 1932-S

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    See semi-rare column

  • Standing Liberty Quarters 1916–1930

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1917 all mints
    • 1918-D
    • 1919 all mints
    • 1920-D
    • 1921
    • 1924-D
    • 1927-S

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1916
    • 1918-S (8 over 7)
    • 1923-S
  • Barber Quarters 1892–1916

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1892-S
    • 1896-O
    • 1897-S
    • 1901-O
    • 1905-O
    • 1909-O
    • 1914-S

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1896-S
    • 1901-S
    • 1913-S
  • Seated Liberty Quarters 1838–1891

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1841
    • 1842
    • 1851
    • 1852
    • 1855-O/S
    • 1856-S–1862-S
    • 1864
    • 1865
    • 1875-CC
    • 1876-CC
    • 1877-CC

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1842-O small date
    • 1849-O
    • 1864-S
    • 1866
    • 1870-CC
    • 1871-CC
    • 1871-S
    • 1872-CC
    • 1872-S
    • 1873-CC

Half dollars

  • Walking Liberty Half Dollars 1916–1947

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1916
    • 1916-D
    • 1916-S
    • 1921-S
    • 1938-D

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1921-P
    • 1921-D
  • Barber Half Dollars 1892–1916

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1893-S
    • 1896-S
    • 1897-O/S
    • 1913
    • 1914
    • 1915

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1892-O
    • 1892-S
  • Seated Liberty Half Dollars 1839–1891

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1846 (6/6)
    • 1850
    • 1851
    • 1872-CC
    • 1873-CC

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1852
    • 1855-S
    • 1866-S (no motto)
    • 1870-CC
    • 1871-CC
    • 1874-CC
    • 1878-CC
    • 1879–1890
  • Capped Bust Half Dollars 1807–1839

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1807
    • 1839-O

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1815 (5 over 2)
    • 1836
  • Flowing Hair & Draped Bust Half Dollars 1794–1807

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1803
    • 1805–1807

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1794
    • 1796 all types
    • 1797 (15 Stars)
    • 1801
    • 1802

Silver dollars

  • Morgan Silver Dollars 1878–1921

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1878-CC
    • 1882-CC
    • 1883-CC
    • 1884-CC
    • 1886-S
    • 1890-CC
    • 1891-CC
    • 1892-S
    • 1896-S
    • 1899
    • 1901
    • 1902-S
    • 1904-S

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1879-CC
    • 1880-CC
    • 1881-CC
    • 1885-CC
    • 1889-CC
    • 1892-CC
    • 1893
    • 1893-CC
    • 1893-O
    • 1893-S
    • 1894
    • 1895
    • 1895-O
    • 1895-S
    • 1903-O
    • 1903-S
  • Peace Silver Dollars 1921–1935

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1921
    • 1934-S

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1928
  • Gobrecht Silver Dollars 1836–1839

    Semi-rare dates

    Most dates carry collector value

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1836
    • 1838
    • 1839
  • Seated Liberty Silver Dollars 1840–1873

    Semi-rare dates

    • 1848
    • 1850
    • 1850-O
    • 1856–1863
    • 1870-CC
    • 1872-S

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1851
    • 1852
    • 1854
    • 1855
    • 1858
    • 1871-CC
    • 1872-CC
    • 1873-CC
  • Draped Bust & Flowing Hair Silver Dollars 1794–1804

    Semi-rare dates

    Most dates carry collector value

    High-value dates, $100 and up

    • 1794 Flowing Hair
    • 1795 Flowing Hair
    • All Draped Bust dates 1795–1803
    • 1804 (‘King of American Coins’)

What makes a coin valuable.

These six things are what to look for, and they will help you spot a candidate. What a coin is actually worth comes down to whether it is genuine, its condition, its rarity, and what collectors are paying today. An appraisal is the only way to know, and ours is free.

Schedule a free appraisal
  1. 01

    Mint marks: S, D, O, and CC

    Fewer coins were struck at some mints, so the small letter matters as much as the date. Carson City, marked CC, is the most prized of all.

    Examples·1893-S Morgan dollar, 1871-CC quarter

  2. 02

    Overdate errors

    The previous year's date shows through the new one. Look for a ghost of a second number under the last digit.

    Examples·1942 over 41 Mercury dime, 1918 over 17 Buffalo nickel

  3. 03

    Missing details

    Something was left off the die by accident, and the coins struck from it are worth far more than their neighbors.

    Examples·1922 Lincoln cent with no D, 1937-D Buffalo nickel with three legs

  4. 04

    Designer initials

    Initials that were removed after public backlash, which makes the early coins that still carry them rare.

    Examples·1909-S VDB Lincoln cent

  5. 05

    Silver coins from 1964 and earlier

    Most United States dimes, quarters, and half dollars dated 1964 or earlier are 90 percent silver, so even common dates are worth well over face value.

    Examples·Any dime, quarter, or half dollar dated 1964 or earlier

  6. 06

    Copper coins before 1858

    Age alone gives these collector value. Large cents and half cents were the first coins the Mint struck.

    Examples·Any large cent or half cent dated before 1858


Questions about reading the lists.

How to sell coins, what to bring, and how grading affects an offer are covered on the coins page and our FAQ. Anything else, call (615) 893-2414.

Selling coins in Nashville
My coin is not listed. Is it worthless?

Not at all. The lists cover the commonly collected dates and varieties, not every coin with value. Rarity, condition, silver content, mint errors, and collector demand can all add value to a coin that is not on them. If you are unsure what you have, bring it in for a free appraisal.

Where do I find the mint mark?

It moves around by series. On Lincoln cents it is on the front, under the date. On Mercury dimes and Walking Liberty halves it is on the back, near the bottom left. On Buffalo nickels it is on the back, under the words FIVE CENTS. On Morgan and Peace dollars it is on the back, under the wreath or the eagle. Use a magnifying glass; the letter is small and often worn.

What does it mean if there is no mint mark?

Usually that the coin was struck in Philadelphia, which made the most coins and did not use a mark for most of its history. That makes most no-mark coins the common ones, with a few exceptions worth real money, like the 1922 Lincoln cent with no D, which was struck in Denver from a worn die.

What do v1, v2, and 8 over 7 mean in the lists?

They are varieties within a single year. v1 and v2 are the two designs of the 1913 Buffalo nickel, with the buffalo on a mound and then on a flat line. 8 over 7, written 1918/17, is an overdate: the die was re-cut with a new year and the old digit still shows underneath. VDB are the designer's initials on the 1909 Lincoln cent. Telling varieties apart takes a loupe and a reference, which is part of what we do at the counter.

Is a worn or damaged key-date coin still worth anything?

Often, yes. A genuine key date keeps a premium even in heavily worn condition, because the rarity is in the date and mint mark, not the shine. Damage is different: holes, bends, heavy scratches, and especially cleaning cut the value sharply. Bring it in as it is and let us judge it.

Will you pay the amounts in the guide?

The $100 and up figure is a collector-market indication for that date, not an offer. What we pay depends on the coin in hand: whether it is genuine, its grade, and what the market is paying that week. We will show you how we arrive at the number, and there is no obligation if you would rather keep the coin.

Bring it in.
Leave with cash, the same day.

Walk in at the Smyrna showroom Monday through Saturday, or book a private appointment in Franklin or Bellevue.

(615) 893-2414

1932 Almaville Rd Suite 110, Smyrna, TN 37167·Monday to Friday 10 AM to 5 PM, Saturday 11 AM to 3 PM