Why is a resale offer lower than what the ring cost?

A new ring's price carries every step that brought it to the display case. Bain & Company's diamond industry report maps that chain as rough production and sales, cutting and polishing, jewelry manufacturing, and retail. A resale buyer is paying for the stone and the metal at the far end of it, not for the stages in between.

An insurance appraisal measures something else again. An appraisal written for an insurer gives an opinion of current replacement value in the marketplace, meaning what it would cost to buy the piece again. A resale offer is closer to fair market value, which IRS Publication 561 defines as the price agreed between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither required to act and both knowing the relevant facts. The same publication notes that sentimental value has no effect on it. So compare one offer with another offer, never with the appraisal.

What changes the price of the diamond itself?

FactorWhat it measuresHow it moves the offerSource
Carat weightWeight. One carat is 200 milligrams, counted in 100 points.Larger diamonds are rarer, so price tends to rise with weight. Two stones of the same weight are still not equal in value.GIA
CutHow the stone handles light. Graded Excellent to Poor, on round brilliants only.As a general rule, the higher the cut grade, the brighter the diamond.GIA
ColorAbsence of color, from D for colorless to Z.Colorless diamonds are scarce, and differences in color can change price sharply.GIA
ClarityInclusions and blemishes, in 11 grades from Flawless to Included.With the other factors equal, price per carat rises with clarity.GIA
FluorescenceGlow under ultraviolet light, described from None to Very Strong.Usually little. Fluorescence strong enough to make a stone look hazy or oily can lower its value, and GIA sees that look in fewer than 0.2 percent of fluorescent diamonds.GIA
Natural or laboratory-grownOrigin. A laboratory-grown stone has to be described as one.A laboratory-grown diamond sells for far less. Bain put its average retail price at 30 percent of a natural stone's in 2021, down from 35 percent in 2020.FTC, 16 CFR 23.25
Grading reportAn independent lab's record of the stone's quality.It settles what the stone is. It does not set a price: a report does not indicate monetary value.GIA
Chips or damageA chip is a damaged area, usually near the girdle.Clarity characteristics can lower a diamond's value. A cut stone can sometimes be recut or repolished.GIA

One rule sits behind every row. In GIA's words on clarity, rarity drives price.

What is the band worth on its own?

The band is priced as metal: purity times weight, at the day's price. Under the FTC Jewelry Guides, an alloy can be called gold only with its karat fineness stated, as in 14 Karat Gold. A piece marked Platinum with no number is at least 950 parts per thousand pure, and lower alloys carry marks such as 900Pt. or 850Plat. Read the stamp inside the band, then see what a gram of each karat is worth today or check the live spot prices for gold and platinum.

How is a diamond ring priced when you bring it to us?

As two sums, worked out in front of you. Diamonds of real size are valued on their own and added to the offer. Small accent stones and most colored gems usually are not, and we say so up front; their weight comes off before the gold is weighed. The gold then goes on the scale by karat group, and that part of the offer starts from the live market price that morning.

The evaluation is free and there is no obligation to sell. You are welcome to take the number home, and if you accept it you are paid before you leave.

When is it worth getting the stone graded before you sell?

When the center stone is large enough that its grade, not the band, decides most of the offer. GIA issues a Diamond Grading Report for diamonds of 0.15 carats or more, and it grades loose diamonds only, so a mounted stone has to come out of the ring first. The fee rises with the stone's carat weight, and GIA publishes the current figures on its laboratory fee schedule. It publishes no fixed turnaround time.

A report also settles origin. GIA says laboratory-grown diamonds have nearly the same chemical, optical, and physical properties as natural ones, and that telling them apart takes screening equipment and advanced laboratory testing. Our guide on how to tell if a diamond is real covers what a quick test can and cannot show, and for the band's stamp, see how to tell if gold jewelry is real.

When you want a number for your own ring, see how we buy diamond and gold jewelry.

Sources